top 6

this week's mentor:: SIR ANDREW LLOYD WEBER
WHY MUST THEY SPELL LLOYD WITH TWO Ls!!!?
he's the big musical guy, hot shot, big cheese, kahoona. yeah.
Syesha Mercado - One Rock 'N Roll Too Many
she was like CRAZY theatrics and dancing and hip swinging. that's where she comes from, she's an actress... i thought it was okay. i don't like the over the top stuff, but she was good.
Jason Castro - Memories
he didn't know it was sung by a cat. [clearly from Cats] i didn't know that either, but at least i'm not trying to sing it! he was boring, sleepy, why is he still there
Brooke White - You Must Love Me
she stopped again! she was like a few measures in, forgot the words, and asked to start again. it was cute the first time, not so much this time. it was BAD. plus, she didn't really feel the emotions of it.
David Archuleta - Think of Me
um... he sings another boring ballad. what else is new?

Carly Smithson - Jesus Christ Superstar
i LOVE THIS SONG! just because i find it kind of funny... she has amazing vocals, big voice...

David Cook - Music of the Night
from phantom of the opera. AH-MAZING. i thought. some people didn't like it, but i thought it was great. it wasn't just another rock song, it was ballady, pianos, he has a huge, wonderful voice, i loved it. plus, i love that song in the actual movie ((i know, play type thing)), so it was fantastic.

results.
i do not agree with this AT ALL. i thought brooke and jason should have been in the bottom two, it was syesha and carly
what the heck!
and carly went home.
again...
what the heck!
she was way better than jason, brooke, partly syesha, i think david archulety. she's great, and she was out too early.
oh well, such is american idol